Abnormal Test Results That Were Never Followed Up: Can It Be Medical Malpractice?

Medical tests are often ordered to identify or rule out potentially serious health conditions. Bloodwork, imaging studies, biopsies, pathology reports, cardiac testing, cancer screenings, and other diagnostic procedures can provide information that may require additional testing or treatment.

But what happens when a test produces an abnormal result and no one follows up?

A patient may assume that no news means good news. Months or even years later, however, the patient may learn that an earlier test showed an abnormality that should have prompted additional investigation. By then, a medical condition may have progressed, treatment options may have changed, or the patient may have suffered complications that could potentially have been avoided.

In Pennsylvania, failing to appropriately respond to an abnormal test result can potentially form the basis of a medical malpractice claim. However, the existence of an overlooked result by itself does not automatically establish malpractice.

When Can a Failure to Follow Up Become Medical Malpractice?

Medical malpractice cases in Pennsylvania generally require proof that a healthcare professional owed the patient a duty of care, failed to meet the applicable professional standard of care, and that this failure caused the patient to suffer harm. Pennsylvania courts generally require expert medical testimony to establish the appropriate standard of care, a deviation from that standard, and causation.

For an abnormal test result, the central questions may include:

  • Was the result significant enough that a reasonably careful healthcare provider should have taken additional action?
  • Who was responsible for reviewing the result?
  • Should the patient have been contacted?
  • Was additional testing, referral to a specialist, or treatment medically appropriate?
  • How long did the result go without appropriate follow-up?
  • Did that delay cause the patient’s condition to worsen or increase the risk of the harm that ultimately occurred?

These issues are highly dependent on the patient’s condition, the type of test, the significance of the findings, and the responsibilities of the healthcare professionals involved.

Examples of Abnormal Results That May Require Follow-Up

A potential failure-to-follow-up case can arise in many different medical settings. Examples may include:

Abnormal imaging findings. An X-ray, CT scan, MRI, ultrasound, or other imaging study might reveal a suspicious mass, lesion, nodule, fracture, or other finding that warrants further testing.

Abnormal cancer screening results. Mammograms, Pap tests, colonoscopies, prostate testing, biopsies, and other screenings can produce findings that require additional investigation.

Abnormal laboratory results. Blood tests and other laboratory studies may reveal signs of infection, organ dysfunction, abnormal blood counts, or other potentially significant conditions.

Pathology or biopsy results. A pathology report can identify cancerous, precancerous, or otherwise abnormal tissue requiring treatment or additional evaluation.

Cardiac testing. EKGs, stress tests, cardiac imaging, and laboratory findings may identify abnormalities requiring further assessment.

An abnormal result does not necessarily mean that a patient has a serious medical condition. The legal question is generally whether the circumstances required additional action under the applicable standard of care and whether failing to take that action caused harm.

Who May Be Responsible for a Missed Test Result?

Modern healthcare frequently involves several providers and departments. A primary care physician may order a test performed by a hospital, interpreted by a specialist, and transmitted through an electronic health record system.

Determining responsibility may therefore require reviewing the entire chain of communication.

Depending on the circumstances, questions may arise concerning an ordering physician, specialist, radiologist, pathologist, medical practice, hospital, or another healthcare provider. Pennsylvania law also recognizes professional negligence claims involving medical diagnosis and treatment, as well as certain claims based on the actions or inactions of healthcare institutions themselves.

An investigation may examine medical records, test reports, electronic notifications, physician notes, patient portal messages, referral records, telephone records, and policies governing how abnormal results were supposed to be communicated and addressed.

A Missed Result Must Have Caused Harm

This is one of the most important parts of a potential malpractice case.

Suppose an imaging study identified an abnormality, but a physician never contacted the patient. If subsequent evaluation shows that following up immediately would not have changed the patient’s diagnosis, treatment, or outcome, proving a malpractice case may be difficult.

The situation may be different when the delay allows a disease to progress or reduces the patient’s opportunity for effective treatment.

Pennsylvania medical malpractice law recognizes an “increased risk of harm” theory in appropriate cases. When competent medical evidence shows that a healthcare provider’s negligent conduct increased the risk of the harm that ultimately occurred, a jury may determine whether that conduct was a substantial factor in producing the patient’s injury.

For example, an overlooked abnormal result could potentially have serious consequences when it delays the diagnosis of cancer, infection, cardiovascular disease, neurological conditions, or other illnesses in which timely treatment can affect the outcome.

What If the Patient Did Not Learn About the Abnormal Result Until Much Later?

Timing can be particularly complicated in these cases because a patient may have no reason to know that an abnormal result was sitting in a medical record.

Pennsylvania generally applies a two-year statute of limitations to actions seeking damages for personal injuries caused by negligence. However, Pennsylvania also recognizes a discovery rule that can affect when the limitations period begins in circumstances where an injury or its cause was not known and was not reasonably knowable despite the exercise of reasonable diligence. Whether the discovery rule applies is highly fact-specific.

Someone who discovers that an abnormal test result may have been overlooked should therefore avoid assuming that it is either too late—or that plenty of time remains—to investigate a potential claim.

What Should You Do If You Discover an Old Abnormal Test Result?

Your immediate priority should be your health. Discuss the finding with an appropriate healthcare provider and determine whether additional testing or treatment is necessary.

It can also be helpful to obtain copies of relevant medical records, including the original test report and records showing what happened afterward. Establishing a timeline can be especially important:

  • When was the test ordered?
  • When was it performed?
  • When were the results available?
  • Which providers received or reviewed them?
  • Was the patient ever notified?
  • When was additional evaluation finally performed?
  • Did the patient’s condition change during the delay?

Those facts can help medical experts and attorneys determine whether the care provided met accepted professional standards and whether the delay resulted in a legally compensable injury.

Talk With Cooper Schall & Levy, P.C. About a Potential Failure-to-Diagnose Claim

Discovering that an important medical result may have been overlooked can raise serious questions about whether earlier action could have changed the outcome.

These cases often require a detailed review of medical records, the responsibilities of the healthcare providers involved, the applicable standard of care, and medical evidence regarding what difference timely follow-up would have made.

If you or a family member suffered serious harm after an abnormal test result was not appropriately addressed, Cooper Schall & Levy, P.C. can review the circumstances and discuss whether you may have grounds for a Pennsylvania medical malpractice claim.